Illegal archaeological excavations

Chersonesus

General information

Location

City - Sevastopol city
Autonomous Republic of Crimea

Kind of cultural heritage

Archaeological

Object type

Complexes

Research zone

Map

Object history and violation description

INFORMATION UPDATED


Chersonesus is the cornerstone of Crimean history. On the one hand, it is a site that embodies the penetration of civilization into Crimea and its transformative effect on the local barbaric environment, which turned into a genuine ancient society. It tells a story of the real Hellenes, the power of Roman emperors and legions and Byzantine intrigues. On the other hand, Chersonesus is a case of the great creative potential of the local barbarians, the story of their ability to take the best from the outside without losing themselves. Here, pride of place belongs to the Cumans with their steppe culture in the very heart of the sanctuary of any city – the artisan quarters, and the proto-Bulgarians, who deeply infiltrated the Byzantine bureaucracy and nobility, the Circassian masters of Mangup, seeking to bring the dead city back to life. This wonderful and complex history of the ancient city is lost in the classical sense: time has deprived us of its chronicles. Therefore, the archeology of Chersonesus is its comprehensive fossilized chronicle.


The ruins of Tauric Chersonesus are located on the shore of the modern Karantynna (Chersonenus) Bay in Akyar-Sevastopol. The ancient city is a walled promontory of more than 40 hectares with a single complex of suburban infrastructure in the form of ancient necropolises, pottery workshops with large-scale furnace complexes, suburban monasteries and the city posad. Unfortunately, a large part of the suburban territory, located behind its defensive wall and blocked by the continuous urban development of the Gagarin district of Akyar-Sevastopol, has been systematically destroyed since the end of the 18th century.


In 2020, the territory of Tauric Chersonesus de facto increased by 13 hectares. For this purpose, military units (automotive battalions and a divers’ school), immediately adjacent to the walls of the museum-reserve, were liquidated. On the vacated territory, the occupation authorities plan to build a complex consisting of museum infrastructure (administrative buildings, ancient, medieval and Christian halls), premises of the Artek children’s center, general education and art schools, and a hotel complex. In ancient times, this was the southern suburb of Chersonesus. As a result of research on the site at the end of the 19th and the early 20th centuries, a large necropolis (called “southern”) and pottery workshops of the Hellenistic era were found here. In the mid-20th century, a pottery workshop – according to the conclusion of archaeologists, also Hellenistic – was traced further west from the walls of the Citadel of Chersonesus. In the early 2000s, it could already be stated that the necropolis comprised Roman and medieval sections.


Chersonesus was founded in 422–421 BC. The possible date of birth of the city is 533–532 BC. During its existence, Chersonesus experienced at least one large-scale dereliction around the 11th century, when its territory was catastrophically reduced to such an extent that a large pottery workshop was located in front of the main temple of the entire Chersonese metropolis (usually such craft centers were located on the outskirts). Having experienced its last rise and prosperity in the 12th–13th centuries, the ancient city fell into decline at the end of the 13th century. It lost its urban appearance somewhere in the first half of the 14th century. However, in the 15th century on the castle of the rulers of Theodoro was located here, which symbolized in the medieval society of the southwest Crimea an inseparable historical connection and political continuity between Mangup and Chersonesus. Despite the final demise of all the settlements on the site of the ancient city no later than the 3rd quarter of the 15th century, it was still remembered as Ierizon – amazing ruins and a pier – until the end of the 18th century, when Akyar-Sevastopol was founded.


Nowadays, Chersonesus consists of ruined defensive walls, city quarters (at least 100), sanctuaries, pagan temples, basilica churches, cross-domed and quarter churches, monasteries, synagogues, quarter cemeteries, wineries, shops, taverns, inns, almshouses, craft workshops. and a port.


The occupation had a detrimental effect on the scientific exploration of Chersonesus. It is no exaggeration to say that the main research center of the ancient city — the Chersonesus National Reserve — has practically lost its scientific archaeological school. In 2014, the latest (already illicit) excavations took place in the northern part of the settlement (Quarter IX “A”). In 2015, attempts to resume research in the Central District (quarter XL, explored by the Polish-Ukrainian expedition) in the new occupation realities proved futile. Since 2016, sporadic scientific work has been carried out on the territory of the quarter in the Southern Gate and the Southern Necropolis. In 2017, the same works were carried out in quarter L (previously explored by the American-Ukrainian expedition). The “old school” was replaced by an expedition of the State Hermitage Museum (quarter XX) and an underwater archaeological expedition of the museum-reserve itself was formed.


At the same time, the ancient city, a UNESCO site, is exposed to active “rescue” archeology: simply put, illicit excavations “for demolition” are being carried out on its territory. These include projects of capital site improvement, both of the settlement itself (in 2018, the necropolis in tower I and the peribolos (an enclosed court) in the Zeno tower; in 2019, the Citadel), and in the immediate surrounding area (2016 – the western suburban necropolis; 2017 – the necropolis in the Pisochna Bay; 2019 – the cemetery of All Saints or the necropolis on Maiden’s Hill; 2020–2021 – city suburbs in the Chersonese gully).


Another no less important factor in the destruction of Chersonesus is the museification and restoration projects at the site. The Opera in Chersonesus project is an example of the museification projects. Within its borders, a stage, an open audience hall, and theatrical lighting and sound equipment are installed every summer on the territory of the Citadel and the Port quarter. Such buildings have a scale incomparable not only with ancient and medieval ruins of city manors and defensive walls but also with the monumental St. Volodymyr's Cathedral, which against their background is perceived as a small toy. As a result, in about a month, the landscape of the ancient city in the Port area changed beyond recognition and lost its historical integrity. The annual installation and dismantling of such a volume of equipment places an excessive burden on archaeological remains. In 2018, the western defensive wall in the Citadel was “restored” in a short period of time. The haste of the works and their local character, however, cast doubt on their ability to completely eliminate the danger of loss of archaeological objects during the festival.


The biggest losses to the archaeological heritage of Chersonesus were caused by the illicit “excavation” of its suburbs “for demolition” in 2020–2021. Russian archaeologists faced the task of clearing the site for the construction of objects from the “wishlist” of the Russian Orthodox Church and President Putin of Russia. The territory, on which large-scale construction work is currently underway, has been under close scrutiny of Chersonesus researchers since the very moment the museum was founded at the end of the 19th century. That said, due to the location of military facilities here, its exploration was sporadic.


In the end, despite the scale of the works, the most vivid and valuable finds still come from other areas of exploration, where excavation methods continue are still abided by. For example, in 2018, a unique chalcedony stamp from the late 4th – early 3rd century BC was discovered in quarter XX, which belonged to the Chersonesian official Heraclius. Such stamps were used, in particular, for branding amphorae and tiles. In 2015, a molybdovul from the mid-11th century was found in quarter XCVII (a merchant lead seal for personal, diplomatic and state correspondence) that belonged to Leo Aliatas, the strategos (military general) of the Chersonesus and Sugdeia thema (military and administrative division). The value of the find lies in the fact that it indicates the exact title of the Byzantine official who ruled on the eve of the fall of the imperial rule in Chersonesus, southwest Crimea and then in the Northern Black Sea region in general and at the beginning of the so-called of the post-thema period — the time when local state power and agency started to emerge.


The main symbol of the destruction of Chersonesus in 2020 and 2021 was, of course, the excavator. Heavy construction equipment is used everywhere during excavations in the suburbs of the city. Large-scale work on a complex and multi-layered monument, even with the observance of excavation methods, is a challenge for the preservation of the object. That said, the situation is significantly complicated by accelerated development. The discussion as to whether the illegal excavations lead to the destruction of the suburbs of Chersonesus do not make sense. The main question is how significant these losses are.


There are two fundamental scientific questions in the history of Chersonesus, whose meaning determines the understanding of the entire historical process of the peninsula: when Chersonesus was founded and when the city perished. This is a considerable scientific problem. It is assumed that the last centers of life in the Chersonesian quarters were in the Port district. However, in the 19th and 20th centuries, its upper and most recent layers were heavily damaged (practically destroyed) by the Russian military. Therefore, despite the presence of lapidary findings with the coats of arms of the Theodoro rulers (which museum workers eventually lost), the cultural layers of the 15th century were never found in Chersonesus. The issue of the presence of the Theodorian fortress in Chersonesus is left hanging in midair. Therefore, the question of how the Theodorites treated this ancient city also remains unaddressed. Without it, there is a gap in our knowledge about the history of southwest Crimea, which prevents us from tracing the continuity between Chersonesus and the Crimean Khanate, the suzerain of the Mangup lords, which is increasingly evidenced by the study of their material culture. The southern suburbs are located as close as possible to the Port quarter and are its continuation; therefore, until 2020, it was hoped that the Theodorian Chersonesus would be discovered under the military units by using modern methods of thorough excavation. However, it is now obvious that a large part of these layers was destroyed by Russian bulldozers and excavators.


Ancient Chersonesus was left alone with catastrophic excavations “for demolition” and the development of monstrous structures on its territory. The occupation realities are such that the “authorities” responsible for cultural heritage protection are more motivated to free the territory from the UNESCO site as such than to preserve and museify it. This organically fits into the policy of erasing the ancient history of Crimea and replacing it with Russian colonial “resort” values.


In 2021–2022, employees of the so-called Chersonese Rescue Archeological Expedition of the so-called Federal State Budgetary Institution of Science “Institute of Archeology of Crimea of the Russian Academy of Sciences” (head of the expedition – V. Vlasov) carried out illegal archaeological works at the cultural heritage site “Ancient City of Chersonese” (name given by occupiers – “Southern suburbs of the ancient city of Tauric Chersonese”) within the bounds of the city of Sevastopol. The works were conducted “for demolition” before the construction of the so-called Tauric Chersonese Historical and Archaeological Park.


The cultural heritage site “Southern suburbs of the ancient city of Tauric Chersonese” was located within two former military units of the automobile battalion (2/3 of the area) and the divers’ school (1/3 of the area) of the Black Sea Fleet of the Russian Federation.


Before the start of the main works, all surface structures, asphalt and concrete pavement, which were within the excavation square, were dismantled using heavy construction equipment.


In the course of the illegal excavations, the following were found:

- 57 archaeological objects excavated in the soil and pits cut in the rocky subsoil, mainly from the early medieval period;
- graves cut in the rocky subsoil (of the late Hellenistic period, which did not contain the remains of the buried people and were dated based on similar funeral complexes, and of the Roman period with burials made with the cremation rite);
- Roman-era crypts completely or partially cut out of the rocky subsoil;
- wells cut in the rocky subsoil and lined with stone (with finds from the medieval period);
- water collection cisterns of the Hellenistic era cut into the rocky subsoil;
- stone masonry, probably from the early Middle Ages;
- Roman cremation sites;
- a burial of a child in a Hellenistic amphora;
- a series of cuttings in the rock (Roman or early medieval times);
- cremation made during the Hellenistic period;
- a workpiece of a stone block (not dated);
- a sanctuary with finds from Hellenistic, Roman and early medieval times.


According to occupying researchers, 21,322 archaeological objects have been discovered at the destroyed sites, dating back to the Hellenistic (4th–3rd centuries BC) and Roman (1st–4th centuries AD) periods of Antiquity, early and classical Middle Ages (5th–7th, 8th–10th centuries, 11th–13th centuries, as well as the modern period and contemporary history (19th – 20th centuries). 2,424 items have been selected for transfer to the museum institutions established by the occupation administration, whose location is unknown.


Illegal archaeological works for construction purposes, conducted by the Institute for the History of Material Culture of the Russian Academy of Sciences (expedition led by S. Solovyev) at the UNESCO site “The Ancient City of Chersonese and its Chora – in the southern suburb of the ancient city of Tauric Chersonese – have led to the destruction of complexes of both ancient and medieval times. Pride of place among them belongs to the materials of the second half of the 13th century, which are chronological markers of the last stage of the existence of medieval Chersonese as an urban structure.


One such object was discovered at excavation site No. 6 (the so-called Institute of Archaeology of Crimea  of the Russian Academy of Sciences, squares 102/157 and 103/157) – a well (with a diameter of up to 1.4–1.5 meters) cut in the mainland rock with a total depth of 3.3 meters. In its upper part from the northwest, the authors of the excavations detected a staircase cut into the rock.


The upper part of the well was filled with debris from World War II and fragments of items of the 19th and 20th centuries. In the rest of the filling, fragments of medieval ceramic vessels, fragments of metal items and coins were discovered, alongside processed and unprocessed limestone.


The lower part of the well, with a capacity of up to 1.5 meters, consisted of loam, saturated with quarry-faced stone and ceramics, which is of particular interest.


This ceramic complex is represented by four main categories of finds. These are kitchen pottery (jars, pots); amphorae of three main types (thick-walled spindle-shaped with furrows and massive, high handles; with an egg-shaped body and arched handles, with a bumpy inner surface, a flat bottom and flattened handles); non-watering kuman/kumanets jars with rounded or oblong top, applied relief ornament, spouts with outlets and flat bottoms. They are well known from excavations in the territory of the Chersonese hillfort, although whole specimens are a rare occurrence.


Finds of fragments of glazed (watering) dishes are of particular importance. Some of the vessels can be attributed to the group of early Golden Horde pottery of the 13th century.


Of particular interest are the finds of eight rings, stylistically and morphologically close to jewelry of the 12th–14th centuries from the excavations at Eski-Kerman.


Unfortunately, the complex was completely destroyed due to illegal construction work authorized by the occupation authorities.


Illegal excavations in the southern suburbs of Chersonese in the protection zone of the World Heritage Site “Ancient City of Chersonese and its Chora” have been carried out since April 2021 for the construction of a pilgrimage center and a historical and archaeological park. In terms of impact, they became the world’s most destructive activity for the sites of ancient archeology. In 2021–2023, 85,000 square meters of the cultural layer were destroyed, about 4 million objects and more than 1,500 archaeological complexes were removed (according to the occupation administration). The collection of finds of museum value has reached 360,000 objects, which have not yet acceded the so-called funds of Tauric Chersonesos State Historical and Archaeological Museum-Reserve, established by the Russian authorities during the appropriation of the property complex and collections of the Tauric Chersonese National Preserve.


Particularly valuable funerary complexes, namely the Roman columbarium, the tombs of Ariston and Anion, the Hellenistic heroon, temple, tholos and exedra, were removed from the historical landscape.


Gallery

Additional files

Involved persons

  • State Hermitage - Nadezhda Novosyolova
  • the so-called National Prreserve of Tauric Chersonesos - Sergey Demyanchuk
  • the so-called Institute of Archaeology of Crimea of the Russian Academy of Sciences - Sergey Ushakov
  • - Ministry of Culture of the Russian Federation
  • - The so-called Institute of Archaeology of Crimea of the Russian Academy of Sciences
  • head of the so-called Chersonese Protective Archeological Expedition of the so-called Federal State Budgetary Institution of Science “Institute of Archeology of Crimea of the Russian Academy of Sciences” - Vladimir Vlasov
  • - Institute of Archaeology of the Russian Academy of Sciences
  • a leading research fellow of the Department of the History of Ancient Culture of the Institute for the History of Material Culture of the Russian Academy of Sciences (recipient of a permit to conduct archaeological works) - Yuriy Vinogradov
  • a research fellow of the Department of Rescue Archeology of the Institute for the History of Material Culture of the Russian Academy of Sciences, PhD in History - Sergey Solovyov
  • - My History Fund
  • - Patriarchal Council for Culture of the Russian Orthodox Church
  • - Institute for the History of Material Culture of the Russian Academy of Sciences

Video gallery

information is clarified

Sources

Links